When two roofing bids arrive, the dollar amount on the last page is only one line. The rest of the proposal is what you actually buy: the license behind the work, who pulls the permit, what underlayment and flashings are specified, how the roof is attached, and which warranties apply if something goes wrong.
The lowest bid is not always the lowest cost. Before you sign, put the bids side by side and walk through the points below. This checklist is written for homeowners in Lee and Collier counties, Florida. It does not name other companies. It is a way to read any proposal fairly, including ours.
Kelly Roofing has been a family company since 1972, with 75,000+ roof projects completed. We replace tile, metal, shingle, and flat roofs on existing homes and buildings in Lee and Collier counties only. We do not do new construction. Florida Certified Roofing Contractor license CCC1325948. Call (239) 435-0014.
1. Look up the license
A Florida certified roofing contractor license starts with CCC. Look it up at MyFloridaLicense.com, the state’s official license portal. Check that the status is current and active, and that the company name and address match the proposal in your hand.
Kelly Roofing’s license is CCC1325948. The same lookup works for any roofer you are considering. A certified license is issued by the state and is valid statewide, but Kelly Roofing works only in Lee and Collier counties.
2. Ask for proof of insurance
Before work starts, ask for a certificate of insurance. You are entitled to see that the company carries coverage, and a reputable contractor will provide it. Call (239) 435-0014 and we will send ours.
3. See who pulls the permit, and who pays the fees
The contractor should pull the roofing permit in its own name, post it at the job, and schedule the required inspections. If a bid is silent on permitting, ask. Work that needs a permit should not be left for the homeowner to pull, and the name on the permit should match the company doing the work.
Kelly Roofing pays all permitting fees on the jobs we permit. When you compare bids, check whether permit fees are included, listed as an extra, or left for you to handle.
4. Compare the roof system, line by line
Two bids can look similar at the bottom and still describe two different roofs. Ask that each of these items be named in writing:
- Underlayment. What product is installed, and is it a peel-and-stick (fully adhered) sheet over the deck, a felt, or something else? This also affects secondary water resistance, which is one item on a Florida wind mitigation inspection.
- Flashings. What metal is used at pipes, walls, valleys, and edges. In a coastal county, the metal matters. Aluminum is the metal we specify on our metal roofs because, unlike some coated-steel options, it does not carry a saltwater proximity exclusion in the manufacturer terms we work with.
- How the roof is attached. For tile, that includes whether tiles are foamed, mechanically fastened, or both (hybrid attachment). For metal, that includes whether the system is an exposed-fastener panel or a standing-seam panel, and which Premier Metal Roofing Florida profile is being used. For shingles and flat roofs, the attachment and seam details should be written down too.
- Ventilation and accessories. Are attic vents, drip edge, and related pieces included, or listed as allowances or options?
- The manufacturer and the product line. Metal roof and flat roof are categories, not products. Our metal manufacturer is Premier Metal Roofing Florida. Our flat and low-slope work uses Duro-Last.
You can compare our systems on the tile roof replacement, metal roof replacement, shingle roof replacement, and flat roof replacement pages. If you are deciding between a repair and a replacement on a tile roof, see tile roof repair as well.
5. How rotted wood will be priced
Once the old roof is off, crews sometimes find decking or fascia that has to be replaced. A clear bid says, before work starts, how that wood will be measured and priced — for example, a per-sheet or per-linear-foot figure — so you are not surprised mid-job. If a bid has no wood-repair term, ask for one in writing.
6. Warranties, in writing
A warranty is only as good as the company that stands behind it, and only as clear as the document you are given. On each bid, check:
- Who warrants the workmanship, and for how many years.
- Whether that workmanship warranty transfers if you sell the home, and what notice is required.
- Which manufacturer warranties apply to the materials, and whether those terms are written into the proposal.
- What is excluded (for example, storm damage, work done later by others, or a lack of maintenance).
On a Kelly Roofing replacement, our workmanship warranty is 10 years and is transferable to a later owner of the property, provided we are notified in writing within 30 days of the transfer. Manufacturer warranty years vary by system and are named in the proposal. Shingle replacements may carry a Kelly workmanship term of 5, 7, or 10 years depending on the options chosen; Owens Corning Platinum warranties, which Kelly can offer as an Owens Corning Platinum Preferred Contractor, include a lifetime workmanship warranty from the manufacturer’s program. Tile repairs carry a shorter 1- to 2-year workmanship warranty (2 years with Roofiversary). Ask us to show you the warranty documents with the proposal.
7. Whether the company is likely to be here later
A long warranty from a company that does not last is not much protection. Kelly Roofing has been a family company since 1972 and still works only in Lee and Collier counties.
8. After the storm, who will honor the warranty?
After Hurricane Irma in 2017 and Hurricane Ian in 2022, many roofers came into Lee and Collier counties to chase the storm work, then went out of business. Homeowners and building owners were left with roofs only a few years old and no contractor left to honor the workmanship warranty. By our count, more than 10,000 roofs in our area, only a few years old, have been left without a roofer’s warranty because the contractors who installed them went out of business.
A warranty is only as good as the company that remains to stand behind it. Kelly Roofing has been a family company since 1972, with 75,000+ roof projects completed. We still work only in Lee and Collier counties. On every reroof we install, our workmanship warranty is 10 years and is transferable to a later owner of the property, provided we are notified in writing within 30 days of the transfer.
If a different company installed your roof and that company is gone, our Roofiversary program is how we can help. Roofiversary is a free, every-other-year inspection. Most roofing manufacturers require documented periodic inspections by a certified contractor to keep a material warranty valid. Even if Kelly Roofing did not install your roof, once we have inspected it, we will back it with our own two-year warranty. Roof maintenance and cleaning, if you want those, are separate paid services. See Roofiversary, or call (239) 435-0014.
A short checklist you can keep next to the bids
Use this as a side-by-side list. If a line is blank on one bid, ask the contractor to fill it in writing before you sign.
- License number, looked up at MyFloridaLicense.com, current and active, name and address matching the proposal.
- Certificate of insurance provided.
- Permit pulled in the contractor’s name; who pays the permitting fees.
- Underlayment product, named.
- Flashing metal, named.
- Attachment method, named (and, for metal, the panel profile and manufacturer).
- Ventilation and accessories, included or optional, named.
- Wood-repair pricing, in writing, before work starts.
- Workmanship warranty: who backs it, how many years, and whether it transfers.
- Manufacturer warranties, named in the proposal.
- How long the company has been here, and who will honor the warranty if something goes wrong later.
- Written proposal, not a handshake or a cash-only request for full payment up front.
Frequently asked questions
What should I compare on two roofing bids besides the price?
Start with the license, insurance, and who pulls the permit. Then compare the roof system in writing: underlayment, flashing metal, how the roof is attached, and which accessories are included. Finish with the workmanship and manufacturer warranties, including whether the workmanship warranty transfers if you sell the home, and how rotted wood will be priced if it is found after the old roof comes off.
How do I check a Florida roofer’s license?
Go to MyFloridaLicense.com, the Florida Department of Business and Professional Regulation license lookup. Search by license number or by company name. A state-certified roofing license starts with CCC. Check that the status is current and active and that the name and address match the company on the proposal. Kelly Roofing’s license is CCC1325948.
Who should pull the roofing permit, and who pays the fees?
The contractor should pull the permit in its own name, post it at the job, and schedule the required inspections. Kelly Roofing pays all permitting fees on the jobs we permit. When you compare bids, confirm that permit fees are included and that you are not being asked to pull the permit yourself.
If I sell my home, does the workmanship warranty transfer?
It depends on the contractor and the document. Kelly Roofing’s 10-year workmanship warranty on a replacement is transferable to a later owner of the property, provided Kelly Roofing is notified in writing within 30 days of the transfer. Ask every bidder to put the transfer rule in writing. Manufacturer warranties have their own transfer rules, which should be named in the proposal.
Can two bids with similar prices still describe different roofs?
Yes. Tile, metal, shingle, and flat are categories. The underlayment, flashings, attachment method, and manufacturer can all differ. For metal, ask which manufacturer and which profile. Our metal manufacturer is Premier Metal Roofing Florida. For flat and low-slope roofs, we install Duro-Last. Compare those lines, not just the total.
What if the company that installed my roof after Irma or Ian went out of business?
By our count, more than 10,000 roofs in our area, only a few years old, have been left without a roofer’s warranty because the contractors who installed them went out of business. Kelly Roofing has been a family company since 1972, with 75,000+ roof projects completed, and we still work only in Lee and Collier counties. If we install a replacement, our 10-year workmanship warranty is transferable with written notice within 30 days of a sale. If another company installed your roof and is no longer in business, Roofiversary offers a free inspection every two years. Once we have inspected the roof, we back it with our own two-year warranty. Roof maintenance and cleaning are paid services.
Where can I read about the roof systems Kelly Roofing installs?
See our tile, metal, shingle, and flat roof replacement pages. Each one describes the system, the warranties that apply to that roof type, and how a replacement is done. We work on existing homes and buildings in Lee and Collier counties only. Call (239) 435-0014, or request an instant estimate.
If you would like a second set of eyes on bids you already have, or a written proposal of our own, call Kelly Roofing at (239) 435-0014. We serve existing homes and buildings in Lee and Collier counties only. You can also request an instant estimate.