Roofing on Pine Island, from Matlacha to Bokeelia

Yellow two-story home with a tan standing seam metal roof by Kelly Roofing, Old Florida style like Pine Island

Pine Island’s communities (Bokeelia, Pineland, Pine Island Center, St. James City and nearby Matlacha) are all unincorporated Lee County, so roof permits come from Lee County Community Development. Kelly Roofing, a Naples family business since 1972, repairs, replaces and inspects roofs across the island. In flood zones, Lee County counts roofing costs toward its 50% substantial-improvement rule. Call (239) 435-0014.

Old Florida, one road in

Pine Island is the largest island on Florida’s Gulf Coast. Unlike the sandy barrier islands nearby, it is made of the same rock as the mainland, ringed by mangroves and mostly zoned agricultural. It is known for mango and lychee groves and a long commercial fishing tradition. There are no traffic lights. Pine Island Road crosses Matlacha Pass through Matlacha, and it is the only road to the mainland. Stringfellow Road runs about 16 miles from St. James City in the south up to Pineland and Bokeelia, where the island meets Charlotte Harbor.

Homes here range from older cottages and canal homes in St. James City, the island’s most populated area, to raised homes and rural properties among the groves. Salt air off Pine Island Sound, Matlacha Pass and Charlotte Harbor reaches most of them, and the trees and mangroves add debris to roofs and gutters.

Pine Island roofing services

Repairs that hold up to salt air

On the island, we often trace leaks to corroded fasteners, rusted flashing and failing vent boots. We replace them with coastal-grade materials and photograph the result. See roof repair and common metal roof problems.

Kelly Roofing metal roof installation built for salt air on island homes

Replacing metal, shingle, tile or flat roofs

You’ll find every roof type on Pine Island: metal on cottages and rural homes, shingle and tile on many canal homes, and low-slope or flat roofs over porches and commercial buildings. Because there is one road on and off the island, we plan deliveries and dumpster swaps carefully so your project runs smoothly.

Inspections for island homes

A photo-documented inspection is useful when you are buying on the island, renewing insurance, or deciding whether to repair or replace. It can also help you plan around the County’s flood-cost rule, explained below.

Tan metal roof on a Southwest Florida home, inspected by Kelly Roofing

Permits and the flood-cost rule on Pine Island

Pine Island and Matlacha are unincorporated, so Lee County Community Development reviews and inspects roof work. The Lee Plan also includes a Greater Pine Island community plan focused on protecting the island’s rural character. For a roof permit:

  • The application is filed online in eConnect, and every shingle, panel, tile and underlayment on the job is identified by its state approval number, rated for the wind loads at your address.
  • Heavier tile cannot replace a lighter shingle or metal roof until an engineer signs off on the framing, and any job above $5,000 starts with a Notice of Commencement recorded at the Clerk’s office.
  • For buildings in a flood hazard area, Lee County counts roofing repairs and replacements as improvement costs. Those costs add up over the look-back period in the County’s Land Development Code, and if they reach 50% of the structure’s market value, the County can require the building to be brought into compliance with flood rules.

That last point is why we give island homeowners clear, itemized job values, and why it can make sense to plan a roof together with any other work you are considering.

Pine Island roofing FAQs

Is Pine Island its own city?

No. Bokeelia, Pineland, Pine Island Center, St. James City and Matlacha are all unincorporated Lee County. Permits go through Lee County Community Development.

Do you serve Matlacha too?

Yes. Matlacha is on its own small island along Pine Island Road, and it is part of the same Lee County service area.

Do you work on the boat-access islands in Pine Island Sound?

Yes. Kelly serves the boat-access islands, including Useppa, Cabbage Key and North Captiva. Tell us about dock access when you call, and we’ll plan the job with you.

If my house is in a flood zone, does the roof job matter for the 50% rule?

It does. Lee County’s cost worksheet lists roofing among the items it adds up, so a re-roof combines with any remodeling, repairs or additions you do in the same window. An itemized price from us makes that conversation with the County much easier.

Is metal a good choice near the water?

Metal can perform very well on the island when the panels, fasteners and flashing are rated for coastal exposure. We compare it honestly with tile and shingle for your home.

Will it take longer to schedule work on the island?

With a single bridge road through Matlacha, a forgotten box of fasteners is a long round trip, so we load carefully and set expectations about timing honestly before we start.

Recent Kelly work in Pine Island

A few recent jobs, described without names or addresses:

  • Matlacha, metal roof. An earlier install had split panels and poor seals. We repaired the panels and seals.
  • St. James City, shingle roof emergency. A leak came in where soffits were missing. We made an emergency repair to stop the water.
  • Bokeelia, metal roof. A valley return had rusted and the pipe boots were worn. We repaired the valley return and replaced the boots.

Nearby areas we serve

Across Matlacha Pass on the mainland, Kelly also serves:

Talk with the Kelly family

When you’re ready, we’d love to help you look after your Pine Island home. Call (239) 435-0014, or begin with an instant estimate. Hablamos español.