If you live in Naples, Estero, Cape Coral, or another Lee or Collier County community, you may have heard a version of this from a neighbor — or from your insurance company: the roof looks fine, it has not leaked, and still the carrier is asking about a replacement.
That question is not the same as a storm-damage claim. It is about whether an insurer can require a replacement just because of the roof’s age when a policy comes up for issuance or renewal.
The short answer has changed. Insurers used to require a roof replacement at 10, 12, or 15 years, depending on the carrier. That age-only requirement is no longer allowed on Florida homeowners policies. This article explains the current rule, in plain language, and what Kelly Roofing can do to help. It does not promise a change in your premium.
What used to happen — and what the law says now
For years, some carriers required a replacement once a roof hit a set age. Ken Kelly, president of Kelly Roofing, has seen that cutoff at 10, 12, or 15 years, depending on the company.
Under section 627.7011 of the 2026 Florida Statutes — the official text is on Online Sunshine at https://www.leg.state.fl.us/Statutes/index.cfm?App_mode=Display_Statute&URL=0600-0699/0627/Sections/0627.7011.html — an insurer may not refuse to issue or renew a homeowners policy solely because of roof age if the roof is less than 15 years old. For a roof that is 15 years or older, the insurer must allow the homeowner to have an inspection by an authorized inspector, at the homeowner’s expense, before requiring a replacement as a condition of issuing or renewing the policy. A roofing contractor can be an authorized inspector if the insurer approves that inspector. If the inspection shows the roof has five years or more of useful life remaining, the insurer may not refuse to issue or renew solely because of the roof’s age.
That rule applies to homeowners policies issued or renewed on or after July 1, 2022. For a plain-language summary, see Roof Age and Homeowners Insurance in Florida. It does not apply to mobile-home policies, and it does not stop an insurer from making a decision based on the roof’s condition or other lawful underwriting reasons. A report is not a promise that a premium will change.
What a roof inspection can document
When a homeowner in Lee or Collier County asks us to look at a roof for insurance reasons, we start with the roof itself — not with a guess about what a carrier will do.
A thorough inspection should include walking the roof when it is safe to do so, and looking in the attic when it is accessible. Photos matter. A. B., in a Google review dated May 4, 2026, wrote that “one of the competitors did not even walk the roof,” while another “walked the roof but missed several sections of obvious rot.” That is not a useful report to hand to anyone, including an insurer.
Depending on what you need, Kelly Roofing can provide:
- A roof inspection with photographs and a written recommendation. See https://www.kellyroofing.com/roof-inspection-naples/.
- A Roof Condition Report, which is designed to give homeowners, HOAs, and property managers a clear record of the roof’s condition. See https://www.kellyroofing.com/roof-condition-report/.
- A wind-mitigation inspection. Findings go on Florida’s current wind-mitigation form, with photographs. See https://www.kellyroofing.com/services/accessories/wind-mitigation/.
- A record of maintenance. Roofiversary is a free inspection every other year, including on roofs Kelly Roofing did not install, with a two-year warranty on the entire roof after inspection and completion of recommended work. Maintenance and cleaning are not free. See https://www.kellyroofing.com/services/roofiversary/.
Kelly Roofing can provide that inspection report for a home in Lee or Collier County. We photograph what we find and put the remaining useful life, and the condition, in writing. A report does not change a premium by itself, and it does not override a decision based on the roof’s condition. Under Florida law, though, an inspection that shows five or more years of useful life remaining means the insurer may not refuse to issue or renew a homeowners policy solely because of the roof’s age. The inspector has to be one the insurer approves.
Storm claims are a different conversation
If the question came up after a storm, the path is different. Then the work is to document damage, meet with an adjuster when that is appropriate, and keep the scope honest — including upgrades that belong in the conversation and ones that do not.
A reviewer writing as limariasis (Dori and Larry, Estero), in a Google review dated March 6, 2024, described working with Kelly’s insurance team after Hurricane Ian: “The insurance team at Kelly saved me an immense amount of time and, working with my insurance co directly, ensured the details of the roof replacement and the associated costs, were properly documented.” They also wrote that Kelly “modified it to include legitimate upgrades” and that the work “was excellent and accepted by the insurance co with no issues.”
That is the standard we aim for on a claim: document what is there, do not invent damage, and do not leave out work that honestly belongs in the scope. For a fuller walkthrough of storm claims, see our April 23, 2026 article, “How Roof Damage from Storm Insurance Claims Work,” at https://www.kellyroofing.com/blog/roof-damage-from-storm-insurance/.
The “roof age at renewal” question is not a storm claim. Mixing the two usually leaves people more confused, not less.
What we will not tell you
We will not tell you that insurance “requires” a certain product, a certain brand, or a certain price unless that requirement is in your policy or in writing from your carrier. We will not promise that a new roof, a wind-mitigation inspection, or a Roof Condition Report will lower your premium. We will not use a neighbor’s experience as if it were your policy.
If a replacement is truly the right work for the roof, we will say so, and we will give you an approximate range. As published on our cost page, a shingle re-roof is about $5 per square foot, and tile, metal, and flat roofs are typically $10–$15 per square foot. Those are approximate ranges. Your free estimate is the place for an exact price on your home. See https://www.kellyroofing.com/roof-replacement-cost-naples-fl/.
If a repair or a maintenance plan is the honest recommendation, we will say that too. We have been a family company in Southwest Florida since 1972. We serve Lee and Collier counties only, and we work on existing homes and buildings. We do not do new construction.
A practical next step
If your insurer has asked about the age or condition of your roof, start with the documents you already have: the policy letter, any prior inspection, and any maintenance records. Then have the roof inspected, with photographs, so you have a written report the insurer can review — including, when it is accurate, a finding that the roof has five or more years of useful life remaining.
Call Kelly Roofing at (239) 435-0014 for a free estimate or inspection. You can also request one at https://www.kellyroofing.com/request-estimate/. Hablamos español. We will look at the roof, explain what we see, and be clear about what a report can and cannot do.